Have you ever heard a statement repeatedly until it started to sound true, even if you weren’t initially convinced? This phenomenon, known as the "illusory truth effect," reveals that our brains can begin to accept information as accurate simply through repeated exposure. Interestingly, even when a statement is vague or ambiguous, the more often we hear it, the more credible it can seem.
What Is the Illusory Truth Effect?
The illusory truth effect is a cognitive bias that causes us to believe information we encounter frequently, even if we know—or once knew—it to be false or unsubstantiated. First identified in a study by Lynn Hasher, David Goldstein, and Thomas Toppino in 1977, this effect shows that our brains can confuse familiarity with truth. Over time, as we are exposed to the same information repeatedly, our cognitive processes begin to favour it, associating it with credibility simply because it feels familiar.
This phenomenon doesn’t necessarily rely on a statement being logical or specific; in fact, ambiguous statements can be particularly effective. Our brains have a tendency to "fill in the blanks," so when faced with unclear information, we often unconsciously create interpretations to make it fit into our existing beliefs and experiences. This malleability makes vague claims—those that can be interpreted in various ways—all the more likely to seem true with repetition.
Why Does Repetition Increase Believability?
Cognitive Ease: Repetition creates a sense of fluency in processing information, making it easier to comprehend. When a statement feels familiar, our brains interpret it as simpler, which we then perceive as more credible.
Reduced Scepticism: The first time we encounter information, we may approach it with caution, analysing its validity. However, with repeated exposure, our brain starts to lower its guard. The familiarity biases our judgment, reducing our scepticism and making us more likely to accept it as true.
Social Validation: In social contexts, if we hear ambiguous claims frequently, especially from different sources, we may start to believe that “there must be some truth to it.” This can happen in both interpersonal interactions and within media narratives, where exposure to similar statements from multiple outlets reinforces our belief in them.
The Role of Ambiguity in Repetition
Ambiguous statements, such as “Good things happen to those who wait” or “Everyone has their own truth,” are particularly influential when repeated. Their open-ended nature allows people to interpret them in a way that aligns with their own beliefs or life experiences, creating a “personal truth” around them. The vagueness allows our minds to apply them broadly, creating a sense of universality even if the statements lack specific meaning.
This effect is particularly potent in areas like advertising and political messaging, where repeated ambiguous slogans or phrases can shape our attitudes without us realising it. For example, a slogan like “Change we can believe in” may sound inspiring and relevant to anyone desiring positive change, even if it doesn’t specify the type or nature of that change.
How the Illusory Truth Effect Influences Our Beliefs
Repetition has a surprising power over our belief systems, particularly with statements that can’t be easily proven or disproven. For instance, phrases like “You only use 10% of your brain” or “Money can’t buy happiness” can shape our worldview without us questioning their accuracy. Over time, these statements become “common knowledge,” shaping how we approach various aspects of life.
Furthermore, the illusory truth effect isn’t just limited to harmless clichés. It can play a significant role in spreading misinformation, as vague or sensationalist claims are often repeated in media and online, where they gain traction and influence public opinion. Our natural tendency to trust familiar information makes it easy for repeated falsehoods to solidify into seemingly credible facts.
Countering the Illusory Truth Effect: Tips for Critical Thinking
Question Familiarity: Just because information feels familiar doesn’t make it true. When you encounter repeated claims, especially ambiguous ones, pause and question whether you’ve verified them or are accepting them solely because of familiarity.
Seek Reliable Sources: If a statement piques your interest, look for reliable sources or studies to confirm its accuracy. Credible sources will help you discern fact from assumption.
Practice Scepticism with Ambiguity: Ambiguous statements are particularly influential because of their openness to interpretation. Recognise that vague language can be persuasive without offering solid information. When you encounter open-ended phrases, ask yourself what specific claims or evidence lie behind them.
Diversify Your Information Sources: Regularly expose yourself to a range of viewpoints and sources to counterbalance repetitive narratives that might skew your perception. Hearing diverse perspectives makes it easier to identify potentially misleading statements.
Conclusion
Repetition’s influence on our beliefs is a testament to the subtle power of cognitive biases. While the illusory truth effect might make vague statements feel true over time, being aware of this tendency can help us resist unwarranted beliefs. In a world where repetition is common—whether in advertising, media, or everyday conversation—actively questioning and verifying repeated information is essential to maintaining a well-rounded, accurate view of reality.
Comments